Home of Chicago's Finest Oven-baked Sandwich
Regular Sandwich and snack $6.29
A Snack - Comes with your sandwich! Apple, Pretzels or Potato chips
Deluxe Sandwich with snack, side and soda $8.69*
*Add 50 cents for soup, chili or chili mac as your side
The Icons
Italian Grinder
- Genoa salami, capicola, ham and provolone baked on an Italian sub dressed with lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings, classic vinaigrette and garlic mayo, perfect!The Mess
- Genoa salami, capicola, ham, provolone cheese, french fries & cole slaw (Yes, BOTH on the sandwich!), and tomato all on a sub roll. Try it!Spicy Roscoe
- Pepper crusted turkey, capicola and pepper jack cheese on an Italian sub with pepper rings, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo and classic vinaigrette.Pepper Turkey
- Pepper crusted turkey and pepper jack cheese baked on an Italian sub with lettuce, tomato, pepper rings and chipotle mayo.
Village Vegetarian
- Provolone, muenster and hummus baked on multi-grain bread, topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, sprouts and black olives.
Smokin' Turk
- Smoked turkey breast and cheddar cheese bake on an Italian sub roll topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings and mayo.Monterey Chicken
- Grilled chicken strips and pepper jack cheese baked in a chipotle tortilla wrap with pico de gallo, lettuce and chipotle mayo.Horseradish Roast Beef
- Roast beef and provolone cheese, baked on our muffuletta bread, dressed with lettuce, tomato, onions and our own horseradish sauce.
New Ham & Cheese
- Premium smoked ham baked on our muffuletta bread with melted Swiss cheese, dressed with lettuce, tomato, onions, mayo and deli mustard.Southern Reuben
- Turkey pastrami and Swiss cheese baked (not grilled) on rye, topped with lettuce, tomato.
Lighten Up!
Southwest Veggie
- Pepper jack cheese, fresh pico de gallo, red bell pepper, black olives, lettuce and chipotle mayo baked in our Southwest chipotle tortillaVeggie Grinder
- a whole wheat sub roll with hummus and provolone, oven baked then dressed with lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings and classic vinaigrette.Turkey Lite
- Roasted turkey baked on a whole wheat sub roll, dressed with lettuce, tomato, cucumber, low-fat chipotle mayo and low-fat Italian dressing.
Turkey Wrap
- Roasted turkey, muenster cheese, tomatoes, lettuce, pepper rings and olives with chipotle mayo in a tomato basil tortilla.
Tuna Grinder
- Homemade parmesan tuna salad baked on a sub roll then topped with lettuce, tomato, onion, pepper rings and classic vinaigrette.
Turkey Focaccia
- tomato focaccia topped with roasted turkey, lettuce, tomato, roasted garlic mayo and classic vinaigrette.Chipotle Chicken
- GRilled chicken strips & pepper jack cheese baked on a sub roll with lettuce, tomato, pepper rings and mayo.
New Favorites

Italian Meatball
- Delicious meatballs covered with rich marinara sauce and provolone cheese, baked on an Italian sub roll, that's it!Beefsteak Grinder
- Tender roast beef au jus, provolone cheese, with sauteed onions and peppers, baked on an Italian sub, topped with our roasted garlic mayo.The Pizza Pie
- tomato foccacia oven-baked withÊ marinara, black olives, red onions, red pepper and provolone.Turkey Grinder
- Roast turkey and provolone, oven baked and topped with lettuce tomato, pepper rings, garlic mayo and classic vinaigrette
Baked is Better PB&J
- Creamy peanut butter and blackberry jelly, baked on our scrumptious Italian sub roll, simple and soothing.The Don Costello
- Genoa salami and turkey pastrami baked on an Italian sub roll, dressed with lettuce, tomato, garlic mayo and giardinera.
The Heartland
- Roast beef, ham, turkey and Swiss cheese baked on our multi-grain bread, topped with lettuce, tomato and mayo.
Sides - Small $2.39, Medium $3.99, Large $6.89
Soups, Chili and more
- Cold sides
- Red pepper rotini
- Mustard potato salad
- Creamy cole slaw
- Pineapple tuna with shells
- Hot Sides
- Chipotle mac 'n' cheese
- Pasta aglio olio
- Red skin mashed potatoes
- Rotini marinara
- Northwoods chili - Small $3.39, Medium $5.39, Large $8.99
- Soup of the Day - Small $2.99, Medium $4.79, Large $7.99
- Chili Mac - Small $3.39, Medium $5.39, Large $8.99
- Hummus Cukes and Pita - $3.99
- Garlic Bread $1.99
- Pizza Bread $3.99
Costello's New Hand Tossed Salads
- Chicken Caesar Salad - $6.99
Grilled chicken strips, crisp romaine lettuce, tangy Caesar dressing tossed with finely grated parmesan. Simply delicious! - Antipasto Salad - $6.99
Romaine lettuce, black olives and pepper rings tossed with classic Italian dressing, topped with capicola, Genoa salami and provolone.
- Southwest Chicken Salad - $6.99
Grilled chicken strips with black bean-corn relish, tomato chunks, red pepper, romaine lettuce, cheddar cheese and jalapeno ranch dressing. - Garden Salad - $5.99
How does your Garden grow? Ours grows with lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red peppers and onions, alfalfa sprouts, black olives and our classic vinaigrette!
Kid's Menu $3.50
Desserts + Beverages
- Kid's Sandwich - Baked American cheese, PB & J or Cheese pizza boat.
- Kid's Side - Pretzels, Goldfish, Apple sauce, Jello cup, Potato chips or Animal crackers.
- Cookie and small drink
- Brownies, cookies and rice krispy treats - 75 cents? Are you kidding!
- Beverages - Fountain $1.50, Bottle $1.75
- Super catering trays available, you get the group together, let us feed 'em!